Remember the 300,000 metric ton 25 percent below market value subsidized Brazilian lean trim (beef, allegedly--ha!) President Trump orchestrated to lower American beef prices?
Farm Action has just done an in-depth analysis of what that import influx did to markets. At the time, you may remember I predicted it would be a lottery win to the big packer oligarchy.
Here we are, roughly 90 days post-import, and these are the numbers according to Farm Action:
Prices packers paid for beef dropped 16.6 percent.
Prices farmers and ranchers received for their beef dropped 20 percent.
Prices at retail dropped 2.4 percent.
You don't have to be a financial wizard for these percentages to show who made out like a bandit: the oligarchy. Apparently Trump issued this order within 24 hours of meeting with Brazilian fat cats who wanted more access to American markets. They won.
I've been told by White House insiders that Sec. of Ag Brooke Rollins did not even know about this import deal until she saw it posted on X by Trump. She was flying somewhere to do a presentation and it came in on her social feed. Are you kidding me?
These percentages show clearly that the packers are the ones who benefitted. Certainly not American cattle producers and certainly not the American consumer.
Here are two takeaways from this incident.
1. Global corporations control elected leaders like marionettes. The reason these businesses hold such sway is because the American electorate has arrogated to politicians oversight and opportunity that should be managed by the market. Period. The only reason these corporations buy favor is because we Americans have kept shoving our freedoms to elected officials, giving them jurisdiction over things they should never have been given.
2. For cattle producers, the retail price is where you want to be. You don't want to be subject to the end of the oligarchy whip, jerked around like a dependent pawn. Rather, you want to step into the retail space, where prices change extremely little because they are the handle of the whip, not the tail. D. Howard Doane wrote about this--using the whip metaphor--eloquently in his iconic book VERTICAL DIVERSIFICATION in 1950. It's one of my all time favorite books about direct selling from the farm. And the marketing freedoms farmers enjoyed in 1950 will make you weep.
Because it's the ultimate arbiter of the market, the retail price dominates everything down the line. Because they're at the end of that line, the cattle producers feels the brunt of all the pressures accumulated in all the decisions in all the jockeying and sales prior to a beef animal walking into an auction ring. The producer is the most ignorant, the most disempowered, and the most dependent in line.
To conclude, this is the kind of chicanery that made the midterms go the way they did. People aren't stupid. Broken promises. Shady deals. Blurred vision. The Trump administration came in like an electric shock to the system but like an electric fence overgrown with brush and weeds, the spark is now barely a pulse. What a shame.
Do you think Trump will finish his term?