REGS EQUAL COLLUSION

An op-ed in The Economist by Nir Bar Dea and Greg Jenson, both officers at Bridgewater Associates, makes the case for aggressive regulation of the AI industry.  Numerous software glitches in the last week are now being blamed on AI because it can upgrade faster than the platforms can handle, making everything crash.

                  I couldn't help but note their derision toward opponents of heavy regulations, noting existing laws are not specific enough for AI:  "Society has learned this before--with food safety after the Industrial Revolution, drug safety after the patent-medicine boom and financial rules after the 2007-09 crash."

                  These three examples for societally-protective regulation speak volumes about the writers' worldview.  Food regulations gave us an oligarchy; drug safety regulation gave us Big Pharma; banking rules have made it nearly impossible to start a bank or do any transaction without cutting down a forest worth of trees.  We did not need any of these interventions and each one gummed up the works and stymied competitive and innovative market opportunities. 

                  The op-ed continues:  regulation "should be the minimum needed to maximize long-term benefit, or the most reward per unit of risk.  Under-regulate and society is harmed as with the unchecked child labor after the Industrial Revolution."  What's happened since?  At our farm, we can't hire anyone under 18 because it's illegal for an under-age person to operate a power tool, like a cordless drill.  The same "child" can legally be in charge of hurtling 3,000 pounds of steel down the interstate.  It's insanity.  As a result of these child labor laws, we have an epidemic of teen suicide because youngsters can't achieve self-worth by successfully accomplishing meaningful tasks.

                  When are we going to learn that government regulations always, always, always over-reach and stymie competitive diversity?  What if I want to live in a weird-built house?  Building inspection prohibits such innovation.  Zoning makes sure we're all spread out from our work; after all, you can't have a business out of your home.  

                  At our farm, I can cut a tree and mill it on my sawmill, but I can't make the lumber into a chair since that's manufacturing, which is prohibited in an agricultural zone.   

                  Liability is a huge issue and the ultimate conscience on business.  But when government issues licenses and determines the winners and losers, business enjoys a protective bureaucratic shield.  When Waymo gets a green light from the National Highway Transportation Administration, it's no longer liable for the pedestrians it runs over--"we complied with all government requirements." 

                  Ditto for AI.  Cozy regulators absolve companies of liability when their product causes harm.  The folks asking for AI regs believe all these regulations protected society from abuse.  But it's a case of the cure being worse than the disease.  While regulations may have protected someone, they also harmed many.  The greatest harm is stigmatizing opportunity, including positive innovative solutions. 

                  Had President Teddy Rooseveltsky (he really was a socialist) told the Big 7 meatpackers exposed by Upton Sinclair's The Jungle to fix their own problems instead of giving them the Food Safety Inspection Service (FSIS), today we would have thousands and thousands of small neighborhood-scaled food businesses and farmers could easily access their community markets.

                  The cry for government help never ceases.  The most disempowering thing any citizen can ask for is a government solution.  The most empowering option is one where freedom and liberty rise to the occasion. That includes liability for harm.  Class dismissed.

                  Are you afraid of unregulated AI?


Next
Next

TIRED OF ME