The regenerative ag community and MAHA are sending out desperation posts to call congressman and protect funding for the Regenerative Agriculture Pilot program to offer grants to farmers who want to transition away from chemicals.
The headlines blare "BIG AG WANTS TO KEEP FARMERS ON THE PESTICIDE TREADMILL" and similar eye-catching phrases. The Farm Bill, which is now years overdue, had funding through programs like EQUIP and CRP--grant conduits historically devoted to conservation efforts--to help farmers transition away from chemicals.
Congress is stripping out these funds to cut costs. To be sure, I want to see farmers stop using chemicals too. But these headlines make it sound like farmers are completely dependent on government largesse to make changes.
I did a deep economic analysis on a hypothetical 1,000-acre Nebraska soybean farm to convert to intensively managed prairie pasture and cows. Fencing, water line, and access (lanes) came to $300,000. That's a one-time capital cost. Folks, that soybean farmer spends $300,000 a year, every year, planting and harvesting soybeans. In 2025, the difference would have been a profit of $1,000 per acre for cattle versus negative $100 per acre growing the beans.
America needs more cows, not more beans to export. Farmers need to save and build their soil through perennial prairie blankets, not destroy the soil through monocrop annuals. Any farmer too foolish or stupid to see this simple economic comparison wouldn't spend a government handout wisely anyway.
If the non-chemical movement would put as much effort in eliminating subsidies and promoting consumers to buy from clean farmers as they put into increasing the federal budget with handouts, we'd get where we want to go faster. The whole narrative paints farmers as unable to make a decision without government handouts.
The biggest reason farmers make terrible decisions is government bailouts. When soybean farmers get $12 billion bailouts to grow a crop the world doesn't need or want, they suck on the proverbial taxpayer teat. It's time to wean farmers, folks. They're smart enough to change, but they don't need to as long as the milk keeps flowing.
These government programs have never paid for systems that work with ecology. I know because we lease several farms where these very programs have paid grants to landowners to install allegedly conservation-oriented infrastructure. They're all a disaster. They drill wells instead of building ponds. They install stationary watering points with concrete instead of portable systems. They build straight fences instead of terrain-dependent fences. They have rigid set-aside requirements that make no sense and lock up some of the best farmland from ever being used.
These are the government agencies the regen ag proponents think are going to convert farmers? Yeah, right. Farmers are only going to convert when they get hungry enough to want a change. The fastest way to do that is to starve them from the taxpayer nipple. I was asked a couple of weeks ago during an interview: "Why do you hate farmers?"
I was taken aback, but it struck me that if you dare suggest farmers are responsible for their stupidity, you cross an unacceptable line. I love good farmers and good farming. What I don't like are stupid subsidies. We need to quit subsidizing stupid. Then we'll have wiser and more creative farmers. Poverty and hunger make you creative. It worked for me.
Why is it so hard to stop subsidizing stupidity?